Back To Career News

Pitcher Pays for Peace of Mind, Would You?


A clerical error posed an ethical issue for San Francisco Giants pitcher, Jeremy Affeldt. The lefty reliever was handed an extra half-million dollars that shouldn’t have been included in his contract and — despite it being deemed fully legal to keep — Affeldt opted to sleep at night and gave the money back.

A simple typo glossed over in final contract review by both his side and the team led to Affeldt getting an un-negotiated “bonus” in the form of $500k when a $4 million figure was inadvertently written as $4.5 million.

Affeldt discovered the error, sought advice from the union, his agent, and the team’s front office, and was told by all it was his to keep. That’s where the wrestling began, but the tussle didn’t last long.

His mind made up, as Affeldt wrote in his book To Stir a Movement and Henry Schulman reported on, Affeldt approached the team again the next day and had the contract rewritten to exclude the mistaken money.   

Do You Know What You're Worth?

With so much news surrounding the off-field dealings of professional athletes being of the “what, he got arrested again?” nature, a story like this is refreshing and is one to help balance the scales when the athletes-as-role-models subject arises.

And, even more important than considering his occupation or the amount returned, this was a human display of integrity and plain old ‘doing what’s right’. That’s the message I hope my kids take from it when I share the story with them and what I’d hope to do myself should I ever end up in a similar situation.

Gifted an accidental (but entirely legal) sum, what would you do?  

Affeldt pays for peace of mind

Tell Us What You Think

You receive an unintended paycheck, do you keep it? We want to hear from you! Leave a comment or join the discussion on Twitter.

More From PayScale

3 Things You Can Negotiate With Prospective Employers

5 Tips to Negotiate the Best Pay Increase at Your Next Performance Review

Rodgers Megadeal of $22 Million Tops NFL Paychecks … For Now

(Photo credit: Andrew Magill/flickr)

Rick Drummond
Read more from Rick

Leave a Reply

Notify of
What Am I Worth?

What your skills are worth in the job market is constantly changing.